Empty scholar's desk with an inkwell, a reed pen, an open book and a small butter lamp in warm window light

Sakya Pandita: Vows, Logic and Knowledge

Among other works, Sakya Pandita (1182-1251) wrote the treatise on the three vows, known in Tibetan as Sdom gsum rab dbye. It covers the vows of individual liberation, the bodhisattva vows and the tantric vows, with the focus on how they relate to one another. Sakya Pandita is the earliest of the scholars presented here: he was born in 1182, almost two centuries before Rongton.

Another field of his writing was logic and the theory of knowledge. Here he produced a work that presents itself as a commentary on the tradition of Dharmakirti. His output thus spans both the teaching on vows and questions of logic and knowledge.

Gorampa and the Madhyamaka Commentaries

Gorampa Sonam Senge (1429-1489) was a scholar of the Sakya school who wrote philosophical commentaries on Madhyamaka. In a commentary, an author explains earlier works. Gorampa's writings therefore put the emphasis somewhere other than Sakya Pandita's treatises on vows and logic.

A reader should take into account both Gorampa's own explanations and the works he refers to.

Shakya Chokden and Rongton Sheja Kunrig

Shakya Chokden (1428-1507) is known for a large body of work. At times he held views that differed from those of other Sakya scholars, which shows that different positions existed within the school. Gorampa was born in 1429, a year after Shakya Chokden, and was his contemporary.

Rongton Sheja Kunrig (1367-1449) is linked with Nalendra Monastery and is regarded as an important teacher. In time he stands between Sakya Pandita and the two younger scholars, Shakya Chokden and Gorampa, whose lifetimes partly overlapped with his.

How Do the Works Differ?

The differences lie mostly in subject matter. Sakya Pandita dealt with the three kinds of vows and with logic and the theory of knowledge, while Gorampa wrote philosophical commentaries on Madhyamaka. Shakya Chokden left a wide-ranging body of writing that sometimes took different positions. For Rongton Sheja Kunrig, the emphasis here falls on his standing as a teacher around Nalendra Monastery.

How Accessible Are the Works Today?

Today the writings of the Sakya scholars appear in collected editions. Translations into European languages exist, but they cover only part of the whole body of work. On the basis of these editions and partial translations, scholars of religious studies and Tibetology examine the Buddhist philosophy of the Sakya thinkers and the concepts in their writings.